Joanna Russ "We Who Are About To.." (Penguin)

This is one of those rare science fiction novellas that really make you think about right and wrong, the world around you, and what it means to be human.
Russ gives us a story about a small group of space travelers stranded on an uninhabited planet, a story that initially feels like a familiar "Robinson Crusoe in Space" tale, but very quickly proceeds to crush irretrievably each and every trope we’ve come to expect from this subgenre.
This novel can certainly stand as feminist scifi, a rejection of the all too typical “when the going gets rough, the men should be men and the women should revert to their natural role” premise. But I think it has much more to say than that: an effective indictment of the tyranny of the majority, an argument against group think, a rejection of the swaggering leader who says to the entire world “either you agree with us, or you are against us.”
Feminist concerns drive Russ' story, in a quite nuanced rather than politically correct way. I'm still not sure whether Russ intends us to sympathize with and defend the narrator, experience her choices as a cathartic tragedy, or simply view her as unhinged from relatively early on. That is part of the enjoyment though : it leaves you pondering well after you have read it.
We Who Are About To... is a fairly quick read, but it is by no means an easy read.

This is one of those rare science fiction novellas that really make you think about right and wrong, the world around you, and what it means to be human.
Russ gives us a story about a small group of space travelers stranded on an uninhabited planet, a story that initially feels like a familiar "Robinson Crusoe in Space" tale, but very quickly proceeds to crush irretrievably each and every trope we’ve come to expect from this subgenre.
This novel can certainly stand as feminist scifi, a rejection of the all too typical “when the going gets rough, the men should be men and the women should revert to their natural role” premise. But I think it has much more to say than that: an effective indictment of the tyranny of the majority, an argument against group think, a rejection of the swaggering leader who says to the entire world “either you agree with us, or you are against us.”
Feminist concerns drive Russ' story, in a quite nuanced rather than politically correct way. I'm still not sure whether Russ intends us to sympathize with and defend the narrator, experience her choices as a cathartic tragedy, or simply view her as unhinged from relatively early on. That is part of the enjoyment though : it leaves you pondering well after you have read it.
We Who Are About To... is a fairly quick read, but it is by no means an easy read.